Top 10 Best Propane Gas Smoker Reviews in 2018 for Your Perfect BBQ

Are you going to purchase a meat smoker but get stuck of what smoker types? There are different kinds of smoker availability out there in the market including charcoal, electric, propane and pellet. Each kind has both strong and weak points, but propane smokers are considered the best option for you.

This guide is going to provide an insightful source of recommendations to help you get the 10 best propane smokers in the market.

Even more, you will get a comprehensive understanding of both pros and cons of a propane smoker as well as how to select propane smoker. Hopefully, it can help you make your wise purchase decision accordingly from our list.

1. Smoke Hollow 38205GW 38-Inch Propane Gas Smoker

The Smoke Hollow 38205GW, the start point of our reviews has its reasons. It is recommended as the best propane smoker in the market with special features including a black color, rectangular shaped and attractive style. From the legs where it stands, it can stand up to 4 feet high.

The most notable feature of the propane smokers is a clear window and double doors which help the monitoring super easy and convenient. Furthermore, these features also let the wood chip tray and water pan be tended to prevent the meat smoked exposing to the outside air.

Another outstanding feature of this propane smoker is the racks within the cooking chamber made of steels with chrome plating. These racks can be easily removed and adjusted when necessary to offer various options for your smoke preferences.

Pros:

  • check
    Great and convenient pushing-button ignition.
  • check
    Authentic and savory taste is ensured thanks to the double doors which allow the water and wood chips to be tended.
  • check
    Easy ongoing monitoring with an excellent touch due to the window system.

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some customers reported that they received the faulty or marred units.

2. Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker

This propane smoker is another product of Smoke Hollow Brand. This Smoke Hollow 38202G is a two-door smoker type. Obviously different from the Smoke Hollow 38205GW, this smoker is not integrated with a window. This means that the progress of the being-smoked items inside can't be observed unless the top door is opened.

However, its positive side is the double doors, which allow the wood chip tray and water pan to be monitored and resupplied conveniently without the need to expose the smoking food outside to environmental factors such as rain, wind, or even bright sunlight. It is very helpful for the smoking process not to be adversely affected by these conditions.

Furthermore, this smoker has a plenty of available control and power for your choice. Regarding the power, it can send up to 20,000 BTU's through the brass burner. With the external thermometer located on the upper door, this smoker can be monitored easily. Also thanks to the four different cooking racks, the smoking options can be of your preferences.

Pros:

  • check
    Long lifetime thanks to the welded steel material for construction.
  • check
    The smoking process is controlled properly due to two vents.
  • check
    Different food preparation options and choices thanks to the removable smoking racks.

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    No windows, it makes difficult in checking the smoking process.

3. Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker

This smoker is a famous product of Masterbuilt brand. It is a vertical design type allowing you to both cook and grill easily. Due to an igniter, Masterbuild 20051311 can be simply used and operated.

Coming with a temperature gauge, this smoker can offer you with useful and simple adjustment of the heat as well as bring you with your preferred cooking ways and methods. In the meantime, it is also very easy to clean and maintain without worrying about the grease or sticking meats.

This Masterbuild 20051311 is quite safe and user-friendly. The handles are specially designed to be cool before touching, which helps the smoker's door to be opened and closed easily without burning you or your hands.

Made of high-grade steel materials for the body, porcelain for water pan and wood chip pan, this smoker is also very durable, which allows the smoker to enjoy a long lasting lifetime.

Pros:

  • check
    Control the smoke and heat properly thanks to the temperature gauge.
  • check
    Chrome plated cool-touch handle for ease of usage.
  • check
    Easy and efficient use and operation.
  • check
    Easily movable.
  • check
    Very durable and long lasting with a well-built design.
  • check
    Easy re-assembling.

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Sometimes, the temperature gauge is not reliable enough.
  • exclamation-triangle
    The drip tray is not big enough.
  • exclamation-triangle
    The weight is a little heavy somehow affecting the placing and lifting portability.

4. Masterbuilt 20050116 Portable Gas Smoker

This gas smoker is the most attractive model regarding the size of the Masterbuilt brand. Thanks to the convenient dimensions of about 24 x 16 x 24 inches and its light weighting less than 23 pounds, it is very portable and removable that you can take it anywhere at home. Furthermore, the foldable legs can help this smoker easily move from one place to another, which results in less storage space required.

With the big size of the cooking chamber, this smoker can even accommodate a whole turkey to be cooked. It can provide stable and consistent heat up to 5000 BTU's thanks to the stainless steel burners and the cylindrical thermometer door knob.

The containers of the wood chips and water are very convenient to be removed for the cleaning. The wood chips are the part to produce the smoke and flavors of the food, so it requires being cleaned quite frequently to keep the authentic flavors.

When purchasing this smoker type, you can consider buying the adapter for a bigger tank to achieve plentiful heating power for your different smoking needs.

Pros:

  • check
    Highly portable and removable
  • check
    The coolness and convenience of being able to take this smoker anywhere simply can’t be overstated
  • check
    Unlimited size of items to be smoked thanks to the big smoking chamber.
  • check
    Convenient versatility thanks to the use of a propane cylinder

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Quite take the time to cook fully when you use a cylinder instead of a backup tank cylinder

5. Smoke Hollow 30164G 30-Inch Propane Gas Smoker

This smoker is said to be the best barbecue smoker, a real barbecue expert. The Smoke Hollows 30164G is a high-quality smoker and listed in the top of excellent smoker list thanks to a temperature gauge system as well as the system of the push button ignition.

The Smoke Hollow 30164G is very suitable for a family size of 2 to 4 members who enjoys slow and low cooking right at the site on a smoker. Through the adjustable burner made of stainless steel and the visible temperature indicator, you can select the right heat for your favorable smoke cooking.

This propane smoker is a cabinet style made of fully-welded and high-grade steel material so it can achieve reliability and durability. With the cool-touch door handle, it is also very safe for you to open and close the door without burning your hands. This smoker can offer reliable performance thanks to the water pan coated with durable porcelain and wood chip pan with high heat painted steel.

Pros:

  • check
    Perfect choice for beginner’s smoker
  • check
    Highly durable
  • check
    Easy to use and assemble

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some complaints about the packing

6. Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker

This smoker is designed with four 14-inch square stainless steel racks and a vertical space of cooking. Therefore, you can enjoy nice storage of bigger pieces and longer cooking. Components coated with porcelain enamel can help to handle the extended use when the temperatures are high.

This smoker is very durable and saves the heat inside properly thanks to the high-grade steel material surrounding. It can retain the heat inside and reach the temperature of up to 450 degrees with this box. Therefore, though it is a bit heavy, it is worthy with these good features.

It is quite simple and easy for you to do the refilling without the need to open the main compartment because the bottom one can help you then. What you need to do is just to open the door and do the check of your trays.

Pros:

  • check
    Good space to fill
  • check
    Reachable to high temperatures
  • check
    Ease of use
  • check
    Convenient to remove and refill the trays

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Quite heavy to relocate or transport

7. Char-Broil Vertical Gas Smoker

This gas smoker is considered as the best affordable one with good features of an ideal meat smoker. It's a heavy constructed unit, and its overall construction has the worth of the price tag.

Char-Broil Vertical Gas Smoker is an ideal choice for fans of smoky BBQ. Thanks to the removable pans and the adjustable dampers, this smoker is very easy and simple to use and assemble.

It also comes up with different features so you can have different options for any occasions or needs. This smoker is designed with double doors and various racks, so it is very suitable for quite many different kinds of food.

However, the annoying thing of this smoker comes from the smoking try and integrated water, which makes it be accessed more if there is a long cooking process. Furthermore, this smoker does not have the insulation so the door can release the heat and smoke sometimes.

Pros:

  • check
    Affordable price tag
  • check
    Provide high temperature
  • check
    Quite durable
  • check
    Steady and consistent at low temperature
  • check
    Simple operation

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Need to pay attention to the thermometer setup
  • exclamation-triangle
    Limited space for cooking inside
  • exclamation-triangle
    The gap between the water pan and the wood is too close for the water to spill on the wood chips
  • exclamation-triangle
    Smoke leak from the door

8. Camp Chef Smoker 18-Inch Smoke Vault Large

In addition to giant companies that are dominating the industry of smoker in particular and kitchen appliances in general, you are free to choose from some smaller manufacturers. And their products are worth trying not only because of their reasonable price but also because of their quality.

This smoker from Camp Chef gives you two smoking racks that can be adjusted. It is so convenient for you to handle when cooking. It also has 3 damper valves which can be adjusted. They are distributed on each side and top.

The door thermometer can show you the temperature inside, and you can be relieved that it is simple to understand this thermometer. It can illustrate between 50 and 550 degrees. As a result, you now can control the cooking temperatures more efficiently than ever.

More amazingly, the smoker comes with a variety of recipes and cooking tips. They are a great addition to those who want to enjoy their time in the kitchen to the fullest extent.

The propane smoker is equipped with protected burner drum, which enables you to get the best control over the heat.

And finally, you do not have to worry about cleaning this smoker. With its removable base tray, it takes less time to make it clean.

Pros:

  • check
    Door thermometer to help you figure out how hot it is inside the smoker
  • check
    Adjustable smoking racks and base tray
  • check
    Much simpler clean up with this smoker
  • check
    Give you some extra tips and recipes to improve your cooking skill

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some users reported dreadful customer service
  • exclamation-triangle
    Poor packing in some cases
  • exclamation-triangle
    Not really durable

9. Smoke Hollow 44241GW 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker with Window

Let's get through another product, which is also the final one, from the famous brand Smoke Hollow. The price is higher than that of other brands, however, you will be satisfied with all of its amazing features.

One of the most outstanding features that you can see immediately is its expanded cooking capacity. This version can hold up to 6.5 cubic feet. It allows you to deal with various foods, even the largest ones. So, it is a good option for those who regularly hold events or parties.

The number of cooking grids is up to 7. You will have 4 standard grids, 2 jerky grids, 1 for sausage hanger and 1 for rib rack. In other words, the versatility of this product is improved so much.

The design of dual door accompanies with a viewing window that helps you see everything inside even when the smoker is working. You now have better control over the cooking process, as a result.

When it comes to temperature control and cooking performance, there is no need to worry because the operation of stainless steel burners is independent.

On the other hand, if you wish to bring the smoker anywhere, it is much easier with handles distributed on the side. Clean-up is not a problem with this product either.

Pros:

  • check
    Great cooking capacity that gives you favorable conditions for big parties
  • check
    7 different cooking grids for versatile cooking styles
  • check
    Amazing performance with independently working burners
  • check
    Dual door design that shows you everything inside the smoker
  • check
    Save time for clean-up

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some people experience the leakage of smoke which makes them suffer
  • exclamation-triangle
    Not staying lit is another kind of problem

10. Dyna-Glo DGW1235BDP-D 36" Wide Body LP Gas Smoker

There are some different sizes for this smoker, which allows you to choose from Standard to Extra Large. So, its range of customers is definitely much wider. Whether you need it for just a meal or a large party, it is a good option as well.

Some people might wonder how much cooking space this product provides. The answer will shock you as you will get up to 1.235 square inches in total. So, you have a lot of space to cook giant meals.

If you are considering the number of cooking grates, you should know that you will get 4 adjustable ones with this product. Therefore, you can change their position, depending on what you are going to cook.

It is possible to use up to 20,000 BTU's in total, and you will have nothing to worry about its dual cast iron burners.

One thing that we love about this product is its premium cover. It has wonderful impacts on the durability of your product. Your smoker will be protected and covered to the fullest extent.

Its door seals play an essential role in keeping the heat and reducing the loss of smoke when you cook food. In other words, cooking efficiency is maximized.

You can easily see the "smoke zone" on its temperature gauge to know how hot it is inside the smoker. This aims to improve your control over the heat.

Pros:

  • check
    4 adjustable grids that give you more opportunities to deal with various types of recipes
  • check
    Generous cooking space
  • check
    Premium cover that improves the durability of the product greatly
  • check
    Different sizes to meet the need of more customers

Cons:

  • exclamation-triangle
    The customer service did not get many positive comments
  • exclamation-triangle
    Some users experienced the shortage of some parts

What to Consider When Buying a Propane Smoker

If cooking incredible and delicious meat is all you want from your cooker, it's wise to abandon your grilling mindset. If you get a reliable unit, you'll never cook your food using the traditional cooking equipment again. Don't just buy. Get to know the following:

  • Capacity

It's imperative to purchase a smoker that offers you a spacious cooking environment. If you need to cook only for yourself, then you may probably be fine with a smaller unit. However, if it's your plan to cook for many people, then you really have to get a bigger unit that can hold all the food. It's definitely safer to buy a high-capacity smoker with extra space than to try and cram all stuff into a tiny chamber.

  • Dependability

Be certain to find a smoker from a reliable manufacturer. Don't just go for any brand. Look for a product that guarantees great features such as good insulation, enhanced capacity and durability. The smoker should have proper temperature regulation mechanisms to make your cooking easy.

  • Price

Average smokers are normally the best choice for the majority of chefs. However, don't go for the cheapest model you find on the market. If you aren't careful, you'll have poor equipment that won't produce the smoke required for your cooking, and the result will be poor-quality food. Luckily, most mid-range models can be bought for just $150, so get into the market and find the best product.

  • Materials

Quality is important when it comes to buying a reliable smoker, and quality is greatly influenced by the materials used. To be on the safer side, purchase a heavy smoker whose materials are thick and insulated. If you purchase one that is designed using very thin materials, you're likely to have it rough during cooking: your unit will tend to warp and large amounts of heat will be lost.

  • Easy Cleaning

Smoking your meat can result in juices and fat droplets splattering all over your cooking area. Therefore, it's wise to buy a unit that is accessorized with a detachable rack, water plate and dripping pan. To make your cleaning easy and fun, ensure that your unit has all these important accessories.

Workability

Nowadays, most propane smokers have inbuilt thermometers but it's vital that you understand the dynamics of setting the correct cooking temperature.

Propane smokers come with a dual remote thermometer. This remote will alert you when the meat is ready or requires attention. So, you won't have to keep tweaking its dial to set the temperature to a high, medium or low level. All you'll need is to have this remote and learn how it's used. For example, they are digitally designed to send automatic signals requesting you to either open or close your smoker to achieve even cooking.

The best thing about propane smokers is the fact that they have enhanced cooking space. To be precise, they are usually designed with 3 racks to enable users to store lots of stuff. So, you'll be able to smoke all sorts of meat at a time.

How-to Instructions

If it's your first time using a gas/propane smoker, familiarize yourself with the unit's basic working principles by carefully reading the manufacturer's instructions. This is very important and will stop you mishandling your smoker, which could lead to damage or injury. 

Also, ensure that you properly season and completely burn off any residue oil by dry-running it before you stack your food in the racks. You can then ensure that your smoker gives that sweet and aromatic flavor to your meat by following the following simple steps:

  • Step 1 - Ensure that the water pan is filled with water, natural beer or acid. For easy cleaning, give it a foil lining.
  • Step 2 - Check that your gas tank is connected to the smoker. Then open its valve. Open the door as you light up the burner, as per the instructions from the manufacturer. Caution: make sure that you turn the gas inlet off in case it refuses to light immediately. Allow some time for the gas to clear before attempting to light it again.
  • Step 3 - Once you establish the flame, adjust the temperature to the recommended figure using the temperature controller. If your unit's thermostat is calibrated, refer to the manual so that you are sure of what you are doing.
  • Step 4 - Preheat your smoker for about 15 minutes to ensure that the temperature is steady. Also, remember to adjust the vents accordingly. 
  • Step 5 - Add your fine wood chippings (you can also use sawdust) to a tray that is above the unit's burner. Ensure that you don’t stop preheating the unit until smoke is seen billowing from the chimney.
  • Step 6 - Prepare the meat. You can then arrange it on the unit's shelves or hook it inside the cooking chamber. 
  • Step 7 - Replenish your water, plus the wood as required. Monitor the gas so that it doesn't go out or produce a dangerous flame.
  • Step 8 - Check to see if your food is cooked to your liking. If so, remove it from the unit. Then disconnect the gas flow from the tank. You can then clean your smoker the moment it cools down. 

Pros & Cons of Gas/Propane Smokers

To begin with, all smokers can yield amazing results. There's no debate about that. A gas smoker can effectively serve you like any other type of a smoker. Just like a gas grill, a gas smoker uses gas to cook, and usually produces great food.

Pros

  • Easy to use - With gas smokers, you don't have to worry when it comes to cooking temperature settings. All that is required of you is to set the smoker to the right temperate and go attend to your other business as your food cooks. These units guarantee complete control over how you cook and are easier to use than conventional models.
  • Parts are easily separated - This alone is enough to make you purchase a gas smoker. They come with numerous accessories you'll need in case any replacement is needed. This is unlike electric units, whose manufacturers rarely supply the right accessories. In fact, some don't actually sell, some will double their price, or worse still some will require you to replace the whole unit. A gas smoker will less likely to warrant very expensive repairs.
  • Portability - One incredible feature offered by gas smokers revolves around portability. If you're into camping, propane smokers are great additions you should consider. A good number of these units get up to relatively high temperatures compared to most conventional or traditional smokers. This makes them very reliable and flexible cooking units that can be used as ovens.
  • A Variety of Key Accessories - Gas smokers usually come with specific accessories to make your cooking easy. For instance, accessories such as the side burner help users in keeping sauces warm as well as cooking side dishes. Reliable manufactures also include special accessories such as side tables, openers, spice racks, and so much more. You could also be lucky enough to purchase a smoker that has an iPod player system. Other accessories such as the grill gates can go a long way in improving your unit's cooking characteristics.
  • Reliability - All smoking enthusiast can confirm that this type of smokers is very reliable in that they are portable and have an automatic temperature control mechanism. However, most people have a major problem when it comes to gas smokers: having to carry the gas tank, which is very cumbersome, from place to place.

Cons

  • Safety - Gases are usually explosive. They can harm you if not properly handled. Several people have reported minor, major or even severe injuries sustained from gas smokers, especially when lit in an open space. Remember, gas is heavier than ordinary air and it will pool close to the ground the moment it starts leaking from the jets. Therefore, be careful when pressing the button so that it doesn't explode in your face. Windblown flames can occur with some units, and it's difficult to predict if your unit is susceptible to the wind or not. But, honestly, gas is safer than charcoal because the possibility of sparks and other burning objects escaping is minimal. However, if you notice a problem, turn off the knob immediately.
  • Space concerns - Widthwise, gas units are smaller than charcoal or electric smokers. This limited space can’t even accommodate enough meat for your guests. That means that you will have to consider halving your meat so that you can smoke what you need.
  • Leaks - Some models have been badly constructed using thin metals. This can result in smoke and gas leakages. Creative barbecues have come up with methods to counter this problem: sealing the gaps and adjusting poorly fitted doors. Therefore, before buying your smoker, take note of your vendor's reputation to ensure that you purchase a quality unit. Also, demand a good warranty. It's your right!

The Bottom Line

When buying a gas smoker, you need to find a unit that is within your budget, but you can't get one that's too cheap. If you do, you'll end up with a unit that doesn't smoke your meat well. Always consider carefully the size of your equipment: buying a small unit might limit the amount of food you can cook for your barbecue feast.

Make sure to read some reviews to help you choose a dependable brand for your unit. This will make sure that you love the smoking experience. In addition, you will be easily able to cook juicy, tender and complex flavored meats in your own backyard. Again, demand a good warranty!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*