Pit Boss vs Traeger – The Ultimate Battle of the Best Pellet Grills

Another pair of the best pellet grills that I want to show you today is Pit Boss vs Traeger. If you have seen my comparison between Traeger and Rec Tec, then I think that you can decide for yourself which one you think you will like best. However, why don’t you try enriching your selection by learning about another popular brand of pellet grills? Read my analysis below and see if this new option is more suitable for you.

PIT BOSS PB1230G Wood Pellet and Gas Combo Grill, Black
Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker With Gas Grill Combined; More Than 1,000 Sq.Inches Of Cooking Surface
$799.99
PIT BOSS 10537 PB0820SP Wood Pellet Grill, Black
Sportsman 820SP Wood Pellet Grill; Hardwood Pellet Fuel; 180°F to 500°F temperature range
$599.00
PIT BOSS 700FB Pellet Grill, 700 sq. in.
700 sq. in. total cooking surface.; Porcelain coated cast iron grids.; Digitally controlled burn system.
$613.00
Traeger Pellet Grills TFB30KLF Tailgater 20 Grill, Black
Arc Controller with Advanced Grilling Logic; 5-Degree Temp Setting Increments; Meat Probe; Power Source Type: Electric And Woodburning
$613.67


If you have read my previous article, hen you definitely have enough necessary information about the Traeger. So now, let’s talk about Pit Boss.

What is The Pit Boss? This brand is owned by Dansons, the same manufacturer that produces the well-known Louisiana pellet smokers. The Pit Boss was created to introduce a series of pellet grills that can compete against the Traeger. Furthermore, Pit Boss throws itself in the Kamado business as well.

Source: amazon.con

Comparing Pit Boss to Traeger

About temperature

Thanks to the Digital Elite Controller along with the LED display, adjusting, maintaining and viewing the temperature while using the Traeger is pretty easy. From 1700F to 4000F, all are controlled by just a single button.

Meanwhile, the Pit Boss offers a great range of temperatures from 1700F to 5000F. Of course, you also view the temperature through the thermostat on its lid. However, one wonderful thing about the Pit Boss grill is that it can automatically start or cool down.

About versatility

The Traeger boasts of its versatility with 6 different cooking styles but still takes second place to the Pit Boss that provides 8 various ways. They include baking, grilling, smoking, roasting, braising, barbequing, searing, and char-grilling.

About the Hopper Size

Depending on different models, the hopper size of Pit Boss is measured to be between 7 and 14 lbs. Meanwhile, the grills from the Traeger are equipped with bigger hoppers. Some can contain up to 18 lbs and feature a great system that helps to collect ash from the pellets.

About Cooking Space

Source: Another Pint Please via foter.com 

When it comes to cooking space, the Traeger definitely surpasses the Pit Boss. No matter which size you want, from 300 to 1,300 square inches, the Traeger can satisfy you. Meanwhile, most of the pellet grills from Pit Boss have as little as 500 square inches. Although you can find some over 500, they are often designed with a two-tiered cooking space.

About grilling construction

In terms of construction, the Traeger seems to be inferior to Pit Boss. This is because Pit Boss grills feature cast-iron grates with a nontoxic and clear cover, preventing food from sticking to the grill.

About performance

The performance of the pellet grill depends on its capacity to deliver well-cooked meat at the accurate temp. One certain thing is that both products from Pit Boss and Traeger will give you fantastic results in this regard. Moreover, the cooking process is so easy and straightforward.

However, using the Pit Boss gives you a better experience thanks to some digital abilities. In addition, this brand features the Flame Broiler that permits you to adjust the flame for either direct or indirect cooking. That means no flame will burn your meat.

About price

Determining how much you can pay for the pellet grill is important. In case you only pay attention to the price, Pit Boss will be an ideal choice. The products from this popular brand range between $300 and $700, so it’s easy to search for the good one at an affordable price.

Of course, you also find the same price for buying some Traeger grills. But, if you have a higher demand and budget, for instance over $1000, Traeger will come out on top.

Pit Boss vs Traeger Reviews

Let’s get a clear look at both brands by checking two particular models below.

Pit Boss 71700FB Pellet Grill with Flame Broiler

The 71700FB is known as one of the premium pellet grills in the Pit Boss line and is perfect for those on a tight budget.

With an average dimension, a large cooking space, and a moderate weight, this model is quite ideal to celebrate backyard parties for 4-6 people. You can cook a medium pork shoulder, a whole brisket, a rack of ribs, or even an entire turkey with ease. Furthermore, the cooking lid securely closes while in operation, decreasing loss of heat and smoke.

With the digital control board and a great range of temperatures, you can also easily adjust temp to fit your cooking style. Whether you’re preparing to sear, smoke, roast, BBQ, grill, bake, char-grill or braise, the Pit Boss 71700FB will help you produce the perfect meal.

Watch this video below to know more about The Pit Boss:


Traeger Grills Texas Elite 34 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker 

The Traeger Grills Texas Elite 34 is truly a big guy. With a large dimension and great cooking space, it’s totally enough for 24 burgers, 32 hot dogs, 9 racks of ribs or even 6 chickens. Hence, if you’re going to cook for a large group, you should consider this pellet grill.

In addition, the Elite 34 comes with a Digital Elite Controller for temperature control. What’s more, an LED display allows you read the temperature easily and clearly. Just set it and forget it! This machine will do all the rest for you.

Thanks to a perfect temperature range (1700F – 4500F), you’re free to use any cooking style. But, for searing the meats, it’s a bit difficult.

Watch this video below to know the Traeger Texas Elite 34 better:

After All Others, Who Wins?

Pit Boss vs Traeger, if I have the choice between both products, I prefer to opt for the Pit Boss. It’s because this brand satisfies my major requirement that is to sear the meat. Moreover, it is quite affordable compared to the Traeger.

In the end, you are the one who gets to decide which option you would be going for. But if you read this article carefully and take note of the advantages each brand has compared to the other, it should not be too difficult to make a choice.

Frequently Asked Questions & Answers about The Pit Boss and Traeger

Is Pit Boss better than Traeger? 

The Traeger is more expensive than Pit boss, making Pit boss the more economical choice of the two. It’s harder to sear the meats in a Traeger, while it’s a breeze in Pit boss. So, the answer is yes. In some respects, Pit Boss is better than Traeger.

How long do Traeger grills last? 

Traeger advises its customers to use wooden-pellets specifically made for their grills. Each bag contains about 20 lb. of pellets that can fuel your grill from 6 to 20 hours depending on the cooking setting.

Moreover, when it comes to the quality, Traeger grills have a fine build quality and a robust and solid feel to it once they are assembled. And since they are the leading manufacturers of grills and have been around for decades, you can rest assured that you will easily find Traeger grills replacement parts. This makes them durable and enduring. They’ll stay in good condition for years to come provided you stick to the manufacturer’s maintenance advice.

Is Pit Boss made by Traeger?

No, both these brands are owned by two different companies. Pit Boss is a subsidiary of Dansons Inc. which also owns another popular brand, Louisiana Grills. While Traeger is owned by Traeger Grills.

Can you use charcoal in a Traeger? 

The straightforward answer to this question is yes, Traeger can use lump charcoal. However, Traeger advises that only the company’s wooden-pellets be used in their grills and not charcoal. Wooden-pellets are pressurized pellets made of sawdust and wood. They’re not difficult to come by. You can find them at a hardware store near you or you can also order them online.

Pit Boss pellet grill problems 

Customers have reported issues such as overheating, LCD not lighting up or grill refusing to power up. Some customers have complained that this grill does not reach desired temperatures, and when it does it can’t maintain them, usually at smoke setting.  Also, there have been reported malfunctions resulting in unexpected shutdowns.

Insert Custom HTML

Last update on 2021-04-11 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*